⚜️ IVY'S CHAOTIC QUILL ISSUE 17:
THE ASHFORD EXONERATION, OR HOW TO LOSE AN ARGUMENT WITH YOUR OWN FIANCÉE
An Official Grimmveil Academy Chronicle
Filed after the Revisionist incident. The Academy's damaged systems have been stabilized, the manuscript recovery effort continues, and the administrative department has requested that everyone stop shouting at the printers.
The request has been ignored.
The Aftermath, Which Was Supposed to Be Quiet
In the days following Grimmveil Academy's unexpected encounter with the Revisionists, the worst of the immediate chaos had subsided.
Mostly.
The compromised systems had been isolated, the surviving manuscripts were being compared against their original records, and the Academy's staff had begun the exhausting process of determining which alterations belonged to their authors and which had been introduced without permission. Every recovered page was examined, every disputed character description was placed under review, and every editor had suddenly developed a passionate interest in the security of the filing cabinets.
The filing cabinets, incidentally, were not enjoying the attention.
Tuesday had taken to standing beside them with the expression of someone who had personally witnessed a felony.
Tinkerbelinda and Wendy were once again arguing over their respective manuscripts and million other issues they have with each other.
Belladonna had submitted a formal complaint about the continued existence of an unflattering draft and no one is sure if she will ever recover.
Zel had offered to help resolve the dispute, which had somehow resulted in three additional pages of correspondence.
Alice Blackthorn had formally requested a complete account of everyone who had ever touched her manuscripts since the begging of time and any time that may have existed before that. She claimed she was just being thorough.
Rumple claimed Alice is trying to build a personal editorial database in case Pip has had enough of her drama and decides to quit. Alice has denied the claims. Pip has refused to comment on the grounds that Alice will fire her if she says anything. Alice has denied all claims and any and all future claims that may be made against her. She said she's just covering all her bases.
Through it all, Rowan Blackbriar the Third had remained occupied with security reports, interrogations from his father, and the increasingly unpleasant discovery that a person could spend an entire afternoon reading incident logs without learning anything useful about who had caused the incident. He was not pleased. All he wanted to do was read and edit stories.
He was even less pleased when Ivy entered his office carrying a folder. Rowan had long since accepted that paperwork was one of the natural disasters associated with loving Ivy. It was the expression on her face that caused him stress.
He looked up from his desk. "No."
Ivy stopped in the doorway. "I haven't said anything."
"You have that look."
"What look?"
"The look that precedes an accusation, an argument, or a change to the Academy regulations."
"How interesting." Ivy stepped inside and shut the door behind her. "And which one do you think this is?"
Rowan regarded the folder in her hands. "All three."
She smiled. "Excellent. Then we can begin."
Rowan set down his pen. He should have asked for a witness. He would later reflect that this was where the afternoon went wrong.
The Case Against Rowan Blackbriar the Third
Ivy placed the folder on his desk and opened it. Inside were copies of the original character references, the disputed surname entry that involved Riven, the relevant editorial records, and a timeline of the first known alterations.
Rowan stared at the papers. Then he stared at Ivy. "Why do you have those? He folded his hands on the desk. "Would you care to explain why you have brought me a collection of documents that are already part of an active investigation by a different department?"
"Because I found something."
His expression changed. The humor faded, replaced by the alert, calculating look he wore whenever a problem became genuinely interesting. "What did you find?"
Ivy pulled one sheet from the folder and turned it toward him. "The original character reference page involving Riven Ashford. The original page contains no surname error. The later copy does."
Rowan glanced down at the dates.
Ivy continued before he could interrupt. "Riven did not create the altered version."
Rowan read the page again. He checked the dates. Then he checked them a third time. His jaw tightened.
Ivy folded her arms. "Would you like to know what that means?"
He looked up sharply. "It means the surname error was not his fault." Rowan leaned back in his chair. For several seconds, he said nothing. Then he looked at the folder again. "I may have been mistaken about what happened with Ashford."
Ivy blinked. She had prepared for an argument. She had prepared for a denial. She had even prepared for Rowan to produce a counterargument so infuriatingly reasonable that she would have to throw something soft at him. She had not prepared for that. "Excuse me?"
"I said I may have been mistaken." Rowan said flatly.
"Could you repeat that? I want to make certain the acoustics in here are functioning properly. Because I could have sworn I heard Rowan Blackbriar the Third admit that he was wrong."
"I have admitted that the evidence suggests my initial assessment was incorrect." Rowan closed his eyes.
He had been an editor for a very long time. He had negotiated with authors, settled disputes between immortal beings, survived the occasional supernatural emergency, and once spent an entire evening persuading a furious witch that setting fire to a manuscript was not an acceptable method of revision. None of those experiences had adequately prepared him for Ivy when she discovered she was right.
She leaned over his desk. "YOU TERRIFIED THAT MAN."
"I did no such thing."
"YOU ACCUSED HIM OF EDITORIAL SABOTAGE."
"I questioned his intentions."
"YOU MADE HIM RUN."
"No IVY! You told him to run."
"BECAUSE YOU WERE GLARING AT HIM LIKE YOU WERE ABOUT TO HAVE HIM SEALED INSIDE A BOOK."
"I do not seal people inside books. Are we finished?" Rowan did not want to have this discussion.
"Not remotely." She straightened, gathered the papers, and delivered the sentence that would haunt him for the remainder of the week.
"YOU OWE RIVEN ASHFORD AN APOLOGY."
Rowan looked at her. Then, very carefully, he said, "Ivy, you are being extraordinarily dramatic."
The silence that followed was so complete that even the office clock seemed to reconsider its career. Ivy's mouth fell open. "Oh. Am I"
Rowan recognized that particular sound. It was the sound of a man standing at the edge of a crumbling cliff and discovering that the ground beneath his feet had been held together by optimism.
"Oh, so you think I'm being dramatic?"
Rowan cut her off before she could continue. Then he arrogantly said. "I think your response is disproportionate to the situation." He reached for the nearest document. "Perhaps we should discuss this rationally."
Ivy snatched the document out of his hand. "RATIONALly? You want to discuss this RATIONALly? She paused for a second then yelled. APOLOGIZE TO HIM!" She spun around, flung open the office door, and stormed into the corridor with her hair flying behind her and a trail of papers escaping from the folder yelling, "RATIONAL DISCUSSION IS NOW OVER!
One sheet landed on Rowan's desk. Another drifted into his wastebasket. A third sailed directly into his face. He removed it with great dignity.
From the corridor came Ivy's voice. "AND DON'T YOU DARE PRETEND YOU DON'T KNOW WHERE HE IS! I KNOW, YOU KNOW!"
Rowan stood. He froze. The corridor went quiet. Then Ivy's footsteps receded at a pace suggesting that the floorboards themselves had offended her.
Rowan remained standing. Slowly, he looked down at the paper in his hand. It was a copy of Riven Ashford's original character reference. He sighed. "That," he muttered to the empty office, "was unnecessary."
From somewhere down the corridor came a distant, unmistakable reply. "I HEARD THAT! Looks like we might be having Liver and onions for dinner tonight, ROWAN!"
Rowan shut the door and whispered, "looks like I will be working late tonight." He had considered slamming the door. He decided against it. He was, after all, a reasonable man. At least, that was what he intended to put in his next performance review.
Meanwhile, in a Perfectly Legitimate Hideout
Riven Ashford was having an excellent week.
This was particularly irritating because the rest of Grimmveil Academy was having a terrible one.
His accommodations were comfortable, his food supply was secure, and the entertainment arrangements Ivy had provided were considerably better than anything available in the Academy's staff lounge. He had a television, a gaming console, several games, a stack of films, enough notebooks to document a minor historical era, and a supply of snacks that suggested Ivy had been planning for either a lengthy absence or a siege.
Riven had no intention of complaining about either possibility.
He was sprawled across the sofa with a controller in his hands, a half-finished bowl of snacks beside him, and a film paused on the television while he considered whether to continue his game or order another meal.
It was a difficult decision. He was taking it seriously. His phone chimed. Riven glanced at the screen. A message from Ivy.
IVY: How are you?
He smiled and typed back.
RIVEN: Excellent. I have defeated twenty six monsters, watched ten movies, and discovered that your idea of an emergency food supply is indistinguishable from a luxury resort.
IVY: Good. Stay there.
RIVEN: Wasn't planning on leaving.
IVY: Also, you were innocent.
Riven's fingers stopped above the keyboard. For the first time that afternoon, he looked genuinely surprised.
RIVEN: I beg your pardon?
IVY: I found the original pages. The surname alteration was already there before you ever touched the document.
Then another message arrived.
IVY: You didn't make the mistake. Someone else did it, the papers you had in the file were from an altered version of the story.
Riven leaned back against the sofa.
The television started playing the same dramatic scene he had paused several minutes earlier. The game console hummed quietly beside him.
He looked at Ivy's message for a long moment.
Then he typed:
RIVEN: I knew I had an excellent memory.
IVY: You also forgot your own lunch numerous times.
RIVEN: That is an entirely separate issue.
IVY: Riven.
RIVEN: Ivy.
IVY: Rowan owes you an apology.
A slow smile spread across his face.
RIVEN: Oh, this is going to be fun.
He returned to his game.
For the first time Riven Ashford was not worrying about the Academy, manuscripts, or anything else. He was thinking about Rowan Blackbriar the Third apologizing to him. It was an entertaining thought.
The Man Who Knew Too Much
Rowan did know where Riven was hiding. Of course he did.
He had known since the second day of Riven's absence, when a routine security review had revealed an entirely unremarkable access pattern that was, upon closer inspection, remarkably consistent with someone who had a comfortable place to stay, reliable food deliveries, and no intention of returning to the Academy until the atmosphere improved. Rowan had recognized the pattern immediately. He had also recognized Ivy's handiwork in the arrangements.
The woman had not merely helped Riven find somewhere safe to stay. She had apparently equipped him to survive an extended absence from civilization, complete with entertainment, supplies, and enough creature comforts to make several members of the Academy staff consider resigning.
Rowan had chosen not to interfere. At the time, he had considered this a sensible decision. He was beginning to suspect that Ivy would describe it differently. Riven Ashford was not simply a clever editor with an unfortunate habit of appearing behind bookshelves. The Ashford family had Veilborn lineage.
It was an old inheritance, one that had passed quietly through the family for generations, woven into the bloodline so subtly that most people never noticed it unless they knew what to look for. The Veilborn were not a single uniform people, nor did their lineage guarantee any particular talent or temperament. Their gifts varied, their histories were complicated, and their descendants had become adept at living among those who knew nothing of their ancestry.
But the Ashfords had always been exceptionally good at one thing. They knew when they were being watched. And Riven, despite his innocent expressions and his unfortunate tendency to become entangled in disasters, had inherited considerably more of that awareness than he allowed anyone to see.
Rowan knew this because he had known Riven for many years.
They had been friends long before the surname incident. He knew Riven's habits, his tells, and the particular expression he wore when he was pretending not to understand something he had understood perfectly well.
Riven could be timid when it suited him. He could be cautious when caution was useful. And he could vanish into a room full of people without attracting the slightest attention. But timid? No. Rowan had never truly believed that. Which made his own behavior over the preceding days rather difficult to defend.
He stood at his office window, looking out over the Academy grounds, and considered the possibility that Ivy might have a point. He disliked the possibility but he definitely disliked the smell of Liver more. Then he picked up his phone and sent Riven a message.
ROWAN: We need to talk.
The reply arrived almost immediately.
RIVEN: Are you apologizing?
Rowan stared at the screen.
ROWAN: We need to discuss the incident.
RIVEN: That didnt sound like an apology.
ROWAN: Ashford.
RIVEN: Blackbriar.
ROWAN: I know where you are.
RIVEN: I know.
Rowan's eyes narrowed.
RIVEN: You have never been subtle in your life.
Rowan read the message twice.
Then he set the phone down.
He was beginning to remember why they had been friends for so long. He was also beginning to remember why that friendship had occasionally required an extraordinary amount of patience.
An Apology, According to Blackbriar
Later that day, Ivy returned to Rowan's office. She did not knock. She entered carrying a fresh folder, a cup of tea, and the unmistakable determination of a woman who had decided that the day's work would not be finished until someone had been made to apologize.
Rowan looked up. "Have you come to shout at me again?"
"That depends." She placed the tea on his desk and sat down.
For a moment, neither spoke.
Then Rowan sighed. "I have reviewed the records again."
Ivy raised an eyebrow. "And?"
"And Ashford. I was wrong to treat his discovery as evidence of his mistakes."
Ivy waited.
Rowan glanced at her. "What?"
"You're forgetting something."
"I have not forgotten anything."
"You're forgetting the part where you apologize to him."
He looked deeply offended. "I have just admitted that I was wrong."
"That is not an apology. That is a weather report."
"Ivy." He rubbed a hand over his face. Then he thought about arriving home and everything in the house smelled like fresh cooked liver. The horror. Then, with the air of a man being asked to surrender a particularly cherished weapon, he said, "I will apologize to Riven."
"Without saying you were merely following any made up procedure."
"Fine. Without suggesting he should have realized he didn't make the surname error." He looked at her.
She just stared at him. Then she smiled wickedly and whispered. "So what wine goes well with Liver and Onions?"
Finally, he lifted both hands. "I will apologize without qualification, excuse, or commentary."
Ivy watched him for a moment. "Thank you."
"You are welcome."
"And you will stop referring to my helping him as an escape."
Rowan's expression changed. Ah. There it was. The part of the argument he had hoped she might forget. "I never said you had betrayed me."
"You implied it."
"I said that you had assisted a person in leaving the Academy."
"Because you were terrifying him!"
"I was conducting an inquiry."
"You were conducting an inquiry with the expression of a man selecting a coffin."
"I do not select coffins."
"YOU KNOW WHAT I MEAN ROWAN."
He rose from his chair. "Ivy, I did not accuse you of betrayal. I questioned your judgment."
She stared at him. The temperature in the office seemed to drop several degrees. "MY judgment?"
Rowan immediately regretted the sentence. Not because it was inaccurate, he told himself, but because it had clearly been delivered into an environment where accuracy was no longer the most important consideration. "Ivy, that is not what I meant."
"Oh, I know exactly what you meant Rowan." She stood, snatched her folder from the desk, and marched toward the door.
"Where are you going?"
"To find Riven."
"Why?"
"To tell him that at least one person in this Academy has the good sense to recognize when she's wrong."
Rowan stared at her. "You're going to tell him that?"
Ivy abrubtly turned around. "NO. I'm going to tell him that you were wrong."
"That is what I thought." Blackbriar smiled.
She flung the door open. "And Rowan?"
He looked up. "Yes?"
"APOLOGIZE!" The door slammed.
Rowan stood in the silence, staring at the door. After a moment, he went and opened it. He calmly walked out, looked around, stepped back in and slammed the door.
From somewhere down the corridor, Ivy yelled, "I HEARD THAT!"
Rowan smiled and whispered to himself. "Of course she did."
The Return of Riven Ashford
Riven arrived at Grimmveil Academy a few days later. He did not sneak in through a side entrance, creep along the corridors, or hide behind a bookshelf.
He walked through the main doors carrying a small bag, wearing an expression of perfect composure, and looking altogether too pleased with himself.
Several members of staff stopped what they were doing to stare at him. Riven smiled pleasantly. "Good afternoon."
Someone dropped a stack of papers. Riven stepped around them. "Careful. Those look important."
Then he continued down the corridor.
By the time he reached Rowan's office, three people had already reported his return, two had asked whether the investigation was over, and one had informed Tuesday that the missing editor had reappeared without a formal declaration of surrender.
Tuesday recorded this in the incident log. Under Unusual Events, she wrote: Ashford has returned. Appears well rested. Under Additional Notes, she added: Possibly too well rested.
Riven knocked on Rowan's door.
"Come in," Rowan called.
Riven entered. For several seconds, the two men simply looked at one another.
There was history in that silence, years of friendship, shared trouble, private jokes, and the unspoken understanding of two men who had seen one another at their best and, on more than one occasion, at their absolute worst.
Rowan finally spoke. "You're back."
"I am."
"You look well."
"I have been eating properly."
"I know."
"And I have defeated a rather difficult level in a game you would undoubtedly insist was designed for children."
Rowan's mouth twitched. "How tragic."
"It was a deeply moving experience." Riven set his bag down. Then his expression became a little more serious. "Rowan."
"Riven."
"I understand you have something to say to me."
Rowan looked at him for a long moment. He could have defended himself again. He could have explained the uncertainty surrounding the altered manuscripts, or the need to consider every possibility while the Academy's systems were still under scrutiny.
All of those things were true.
None of them changed the fact that he had treated an old friend like he had betrayed him.
"I owe you an apology," Rowan said. "I treated your discovery of the surname alteration as though you were responsible for it. The records now show that. I was wrong to accuse you, and I was wrong to make you feel that you had to leave to avoid my scrutiny. You deserved better from me."
Riven's expression softened. For once, he did not immediately reach for a joke. "Thank you."
Rowan nodded. "I may have overeacted a bit" Rowan laughed despite himself.
Riven grinned. And just like that, something that had been strained between them began to settle back into place.
Then Riven ruined the moment. "Although, for the record, I would never have Ivy marry a Blackthorn. Riven looked at him innocently. I am simply saying that if I were going to arrange an entirely unauthorized marriage for Ivy, I would at least choose a surname with better editorial flair."
Rowan's eyes began to glow. A deep, unmistakable light stirred behind them. Riven noticed. "Oh, good," he said. "We're being dramatic again." His own eyes flashed red.
"ASHFORD. I suggest you choose your next words very carefully." Rowan rose slowly from his chair.
Riven did not retreat. Instead, he leaned against the edge of the desk, folded his arms, and regarded Rowan with the relaxed confidence of someone who had just returned from a luxury holiday and intended to make the most of it. "You know," Riven continued, "I have always wondered why you react so strongly whenever someone mentions Ivy's surname."
"I do not."
"Your eyes are glowing."
"They do that."
Riven smiled. "Only when you are annoyed."
"I am not annoyed."
Riven looked at Rowan. "Of course not." The red in Riven's own eyes brightened.
Rowan's expression shifted, just slightly. For one brief moment, the two men regarded one another with a recognition that went deeper than their argument, deeper even than their friendship. Rowan knew that Riven was testing him. And Riven knew that Rowan knew.
Rowan's eyes flared. "Get out of my office."
Riven burst out laughing. "There he is! Your apology was lovely, by the way."
"OUT."
Riven picked up his bag. "Tell Ivy I said hello."
"Tell her yourself."
He reached the door, paused, and glanced back. "One more thing." Riven smiled. "It's good to be back."
The Editorial Status Report
By the end of the week, Riven Ashford had officially returned to work, Rowan Blackbriar had formally apologized, and Ivy had declared the matter settled.
Rowan had declared the matter substantially resolved. Ivy had informed him that this was the sort of language people used when they intended to reopen the matter later. Rowan had informed her that he had no such intention. Ivy had smiled.
The recovered manuscripts continued to be reviewed, the Academy's security investigation remained active, and the identity of the Revisionists was still unknown. Riven's innocence in the original surname alteration had been established.
The rest remained unresolved.
And while the Academy resumed its work, the friendships strained by the incident began, slowly, to recover. Riven and Rowan were once again exchanging insults across the editorial department, Ivy had stopped threatening to throw paperwork at her fiancé, and Tuesday had removed the word escape from Riven's personnel record. She replaced it with temporarily worked from home. Then, after some consideration, she added a note. Subject appears to have enjoyed himself. No one disputed the assessment. Not even Rowan.
EDITOR'S NOTE: The Academy confirms that Riven Ashford did not introduce the original surname alteration. Rowan Blackbriar has apologized probably for the firstntime in 300 years. Ivy has accepted the apology on Riven's behalf, although Riven has pointed out that no one asked him whether he required her assistance.
Riven has also confirmed that he did not intend to arrange a marriage between Ivy and any member of the Blackthorn family.
Rowan has confirmed that he would have objected.
Ivy has confirmed that neither man is permitted to arrange her marriage to anyone.
The editorial department has been instructed to stop discussing the matter.
The editorial department has not complied.
REVISIONIST IDENTITY: Unknown.
RIVEN ASHFORD: Back at work.
ROWAN BLACKBRIAR THE THIRD: Claims he was never worried.
IVY: Does not believe him.
FINAL OBSERVATION: Riven Ashford was the first person known to notice a discrepancy, not the person who created it. The distinction has been formally recorded. Whether someone intended the discrepancy to implicate Riven remains unknown.
And somewhere in Grimmveil, the person responsible for the alteration may already know that the Academy has begun asking the right questions.
The friendships recovered.
And the editorial department has been reminded that a quiet week is not the same thing as a safe one.
END OF ISSUE 17.